Builder vs handyman: Who should you call?

Sometimes it’s tricky to work out who you need to hire when you need a job done. There are builders, architects, carpenters, tradespeople, handymen, labourers, and everything in between.

So, how do you know if your project requires the services of a builder or a handyman? Who’s going to turn your diamond in the rough house into your perfect home? Is it a builder vs a handyman? In other words, do you need a builder for a major renovation or would a handyman suffice for some quick fixes?

This article clarifies the difference between a handyman and a builder, helping you make the right decision for your home improvement needs.

What does a builder do?

Building is a specialised field that requires a high level of education, experience, and training. You need a builder if you’re looking to do a large project such as building a new home, doing a major renovation, or building an extension.

A builder’s job is not only to provide a physical structure. They also need to know the legalities and regulations for doing so and ensure everything is in place, such as plans, applications, and permits, before any work is carried out.

Note that a builder isn’t necessarily an engineer or an architect; they may hire an engineering or architectural firm, however, if necessary.

Recently, sustainability and green building practices, such as energy-efficient construction, are increasingly becoming important in the Australian building industry. Builders need to upskill to new building practices in light of this movement.

What is a handyman?

There are always jobs around the home that need to be done. Some things you might feel confident in tackling yourself, for others you may need some help. For these jobs, hiring a handyman can be a great option.

Basically, a handyman is a person who is ‘handy’ or ‘skilful’ with basic repairs or minor renovations and is easily available to perform common household projects, installations, and maintenance. These are mostly jobs that require skill, but not necessarily an extensive qualification to perform. Handymen have a variety of skills and are usually available without much notice.

You might need several things done at once, like painting a room, fixing a broken tile, or putting together a piece of furniture. A handyman’s skills can cover these in a short space of time at short notice.

Builder vs handyman: Know who to call

Understanding the differences between builders and handymen is crucial when deciding who to hire for your home project. Let’s examine these professions in terms of their skill sets, project types, costs, responsibilities, and regulatory requirements.

In terms of skill set and expertise

Builder skills are typically broader and deeper, most of them related to construction and renovation. They have extensive knowledge of building codes, structural engineering principles, and project management. Builders are equipped to handle complex, large-scale projects that require coordinating multiple trades.

Handymen, on the other hand, have a diverse set of general skills covering various aspects of home maintenance and repair. While they may not have the know-how in any single area that a niche tradesperson would, their versatility allows them to efficiently handle a wide array of smaller assignments.

In terms of project types

Builders are best suited for:

• New home construction
• Major renovations or home extensions
• Structural changes to existing buildings
• Large-scale commercial projects
• Projects requiring multiple subcontractors

On the other hand, a typical handyman services list includes:

• Minor maintenance and repairs
• Small-scale home improvements
• Basic carpentry work and small building jobs, like erecting sheds
• Basic plumbing and electrical work
• Painting and decorating
• Prefabricated item assembly, such as furniture assembly
• Other odd jobs around the house and maintenance work

In terms of responsibilities

Builders take on comprehensive project management roles. They’re responsible for:

• Obtaining necessary permits
• Coordinating with architects and engineers
• Managing subcontractors
• Ensuring compliance with building codes
• Overseeing the entire construction process from start to post-construction cleaning
• Liaising with the client, including setting a construction or renovation budget

Handymen are generally responsible for:

• Completing specific tasks or repairs
• Providing their own tools
• Advising homeowners on simple maintenance issues
• Recommending when more specific help is needed
• Advising homeowners on do’s and don’ts regarding renovations and home maintenance

In terms of cost

Builders generally charge higher rates due to their expertise and the complexity of the projects they manage. Their fees often include costs for subcontractors, materials, and project management.

Handymen typically charge hourly or flat rates for their services. They’re often more cost-effective for smaller jobs that don’t require a particular skill set or large-scale planning.

In terms of licencing and regulations

Licencing requirements vary by location, but builders must be licensed, bonded, and insured. They must pass exams and demonstrate considerable experience in the field. This is why builders are often costlier than handymen.

Builder certification may vary across states and territories. Some common builder certifications and qualifications across Australia include:

• White Card (Work Safely in the Construction Industry CPCCOHS1001A)
• Certificate IV in Building and Construction
• Associate, Bachelor’s, or Master’s degrees in Building and Construction or Construction Management

The specific requirements vary by state and territory, but generally involve completing relevant vocational education and training (VET) courses, gaining practical experience, and applying for a builder’s licence through the regulatory body in each jurisdiction. For example, applying to the Western Australian Building Commission for a licence if the builder is in Western Australia.

Meanwhile, some jurisdictions require a basic handyman licence for handymen, but further qualifications and insurance requirements are usually less stringent. However, for certain types of work (e.g., electrical or plumbing), they may need specific trade licences, extensive experience, and demonstrable various skills.

Always check your local regulations to ensure any professional you hire meets the necessary legal requirements for the work they’ll be performing.

Build your dream home

When it comes to home improvements, picking between a builder and a handyman isn’t just about project size—it’s about matching skills to your needs. Builders excel at major renovations and complex constructions, while handymen are ideal for smaller repairs and maintenance.

Builders manage large-scale projects from start to finish, handling permits and ensuring code compliance. Their higher costs reflect this comprehensive service. Handymen offer affordability and versatility for those everyday household fixes and minor upgrades.

Whether you’re planning a complete home transformation or tackling a list of repairs, calling in professionals can save time, stress and potentially costly mistakes.

Next time you spot a home project, ask yourself: Does this need a builder’s comprehensive skills or a handyman’s versatile touch? Make the right call, and watch your home improvement plans come to life with the perfect pro for the job.

---

FAQs on builder vs handyman

What is the highest-paying handyman job?

The highest-paying handyman jobs often involve special skills or niche markets. In general, the more impressive the handyman’s qualifications and credentials, the higher they can charge. Handymen specialising in high-end home renovations or luxury property maintenance can command premium prices. Those with electrical or plumbing licences can also earn significantly more, as they can legally perform more complex tasks.

What are building and construction skills?

Building and construction skills encompass various technical abilities essential for creating and maintaining structures. These include proficiency in reading and interpreting blueprints, knowledge of various building materials and their applications, and mastery of construction techniques.

Practical skills involve carpentry, bricklaying, concreting, plastering, and roofing, but technical skills are also essential, such as understanding building codes and safety regulations. Builders also need to be proficient with construction tools and equipment, both manual and power-operated.